
The Fiduciary Illusion: What Most Investors Don’t Know
Many investors assume the word “fiduciary” guarantees impartial advice. In reality, the financial services industry allows dual registration—meaning an individual can be registered both as an investment advisor and as a registered representative of a broker-dealer—enabling them to act as a fiduciary while also functioning as a commission-based salesperson. Is my advisor a fiduciary or a salesperson? One minute they’re guiding you as a fiduciary—next, they’re pitching a high-commission investment or insurance product.
Advisors or Salespeople? Why Dual Roles Can Be Misleading
Many so-called fiduciaries operate in dual capacities, which can blur the line between objective advice and product sales:
- RIA Hat: They offer fee-only investment advice, positioning themselves as fiduciaries acting in the client’s best interest.
- Broker-Dealer Hat: In other settings, they may earn commissions through the sale of other investment products, aligning more with a salesperson’s role than a fiduciary’s.
If your advisor promotes high-fee annuities, real estate investments, or hedge funds—without showing data or performance evidence to support the product—you may be dealing with a salesperson, not a fiduciary.
Let’s dive into an example of one apparent gray area, the sale of indexed annuities—products that have been known to promise market returns, based on an underlying index’s performance, without the downside.
What Can Be Some of the Concerns with Indexed Annuities?
- High Commissions: Agents can earn 6–10% off the top.1
- Limited Upside: Market gains are capped, often at 2–3% per year.2
- Lack of Liquidity: Many have surrender periods of 10–20 years.1
- Opaque Terms: Contracts are often over 100 pages, loaded with legal language.1
- Risk Transfer: The insurer, not the investor, controls most outcomes.1
How to Protect Yourself
- Request proof of performance: Can they show you verifiable, factual, and historical performance results?
- Understand their role: Are they acting solely as an RIA or also as a representative of a broker-dealer?
- Avoid complexity without clarity: If you don’t understand the investment, don’t buy it.
Fiduciary vs. Financial Salesperson
The title “fiduciary” should mean something—but in today’s environment, it doesn’t always. That’s why it’s up to investors to ask the hard questions, demand transparency, and avoid financial products that have the potential to benefit the advisor more than the client.
Education is Your Strongest Investment
Titles can be misleading—but knowledge is empowering. In a world full of sales-driven advice and complex products, the best defense is a well-informed investor. Before making major financial decisions, take the time to understand what you’re being sold—and who stands to benefit.
One of the best ways to start? Attend the American Dream Experience—a powerful two-day event designed to transform the way you think about money, investing, and your future. You’ll learn about the science of investing, begin to understand your own relationship to money, and discover tools to pursue a life of purpose and freedom.
DISCLOSURES:
This content is based on the views, opinions, beliefs, or viewpoints of Matson Money, Inc. This content is not to be considered investment advice and is not to be relied upon as the basis for entering into any transaction or advisory relationship or making any investment decision.
All of Matson Money’s advisory services are marketed almost exclusively by either Solicitors or Co-Advisors. Both Co-Advisors and Solicitors are independent contractors, not employees or agents of Matson.
Other financial organizations may analyze investments and take a different approach to investing than that of Matson Money. All investing involves risks and costs. No investment strategy (including asset allocation and diversification strategies) can ensure peace of mind, guarantee profit, or protect against loss.
PAST PERFORMANCE IS NO GUARANTEE OF FUTURE RESULTS
- Guide to Annuities: what they are, types and how they work. Julia Kagan. September 24, 2024. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/annuity.asp
- Equity Indexed Annuities: Downside protection, But at What Cost? Patrick J. Collins. May 2009. https://www.financialplanningassociation.org/article/journal/MAY09-equity-indexed-annuities-downside-protection-what-cost
- SEC Adopted Section 206: https://www.sec.gov/files/rules/final/2007/ia-2628.pdf